Thursday, April 4, 2019

Thursday of the Fourth Week of Lent



·   Spatial art—art that exists in the natural, physical world, art that lives in two and three dimensions, art that we build, shape, mold, wear, touch, embrace and even kneel before, is an essential aspect of this reflection. Lectionary: 247: “They have turned aside from the way I pointed out to them, making for themselves a molten calf and worshipping it…”

Spiritual and historical inquiry based on the worshipping of depraved objects and craven images—particularly in the Lenten season—such as a smelted golden calf as mentioned above, might provoke the following question: Q: What is the difference between praying through an object of veneration and praying to an object of idolatry?

Here is an anecdotal response to the dilemma of venerating or worshipping objects that are cabalistic. When we ask (for example) the Blessed Mother to intervene on our behalf on an issue pertaining to (let’s say) a specific failing as a moral agent (did we lie to someone, did we steal something?) we might appeal to Mary through a revered object such as Tintoretto’s timeless masterpiece, The Annunciation I. Tintoretto’s oil painting—a recreation of Mary’s terrifying ordeal at the hands of what seems to be an exterminating angel—but is actually a centennial—is both a point of departure (a point of anxiety) and a point of reentry (a point of safe return) for Mary. That is, Mary is both frightened and relieved of her anxiety in the same moment. Accordingly, logically, this is both an ordeal and an event that the disconsolate petitioner can relate to—fear and salvation in one stroke of Tintoretto’s immaculate brush. A model for spiritual and communicative inquiry might look like this:

Inconsolable     > Tintoretto/Annunciation    >     Mary/Intervention > Salvation

·    So Again: Q: What is the difference between praying through an object of veneration and praying to an object of veneration?

·       A: The difference between praying through an object of veneration and praying to an object of idolatry is not subtle. The former is an act of humility; the latter is an act of obsession, an act of extreme hunger and thirst—an act of indulgence and perhaps depravity. These differences—humility and depravity—are not obscure. We as educated, informed, Christians and members of the Roman Rite do not pray to objects; rather, we live in objects, we live in our shared forms and experiences; we live in the ordeals of Jesus, Mary and Joseph, and the recreation of those ordeals by master-builders such as Tintoretto. Moses was many things, but he was not one of the ten greatest painters that ever lived. Tintoretto was and remains a painter of remarkable compassion. Let’s always remember this. Especially at the Paschal season.

Timothy Virgil Dugan, D.Litt.
Associate Professor of Communication Arts


I Tintoretto. The Annunciation. 1583-1587. Oil on canvas. Scuolo di San Rocco, Venice. Late Renaissance. Mannerism. 422 x 545.


The Annunciation, Tintoretto

No comments:

Post a Comment